Knausgaard Gave You All of the Clues
There’s an odd new star within the sky, so shiny that you may see it by day. It brings with it unseasonably scorching climate and weird phenomena that defy scientific rationalization. To some, the star is an astronomical marvel; to others, it’s a portent of doom. That is the premise of The Capturing Star, a comic book e-book starring the plucky younger Belgian journalist Tintin, printed in 1942. It’s additionally, extra lately, the premise of a collection of novels by the celebrated Norwegian author Karl Ove Knausgaard. The third e-book within the collection, The Third Realm, arrives this month.
I as soon as learn a parody of Tintin by which he stored overhearing conversations and discovering little scraps of paper—crumbs!—and the joke was that they weren’t clues to something, simply meaningless ephemera. It’s humorous as a result of nothing is ever random in Tintin’s world; it’s completely organized round him, and supersaturated with which means. At first blush, the world of The Third Realm seems extra just like the parody world: a jumble of unconnected incidents and coincidences. All noise, no sign. Identical to actuality! However the fact is extra sophisticated than that, and extra fascinating. It seems that which means, like a cussed ghost, isn’t really easy to do away with.
Meaningless ephemera are, in fact, Knausgaard’s inventory in commerce. He’s finest often called the creator of the six-volume autofictional epic My Battle, a frame-breaking, obsessively detailed, radically confessional account of his personal life that has turn out to be a landmark in up to date literature. Knausgaard’s new collection is, on its face, a way more standard affair. It started—in case you’re simply tuning in—in 2020 with The Morning Star, which tells the tales of 9 fictional Norwegians as they go about their lives beneath the enigmatic gaze of the eponymous star. Is it a comet? A supernova? A UFO? An optical phantasm? No one is aware of. E-book two, The Wolves of Eternity, is a couple of younger undertaker who finds out he has a secret half sister in Russia. Its connection to e-book one is usually thematic, although that thriller star does seem on the finish.
![](https://i0.wp.com/cdn.theatlantic.com/thumbor/2bRcTcEGs_0oNT8EuEJM__FpuGs=/0x0:329x500/79x120/media/img/book_reviews/2024/09/27/31Z0fM10DJL._SL500_/original.jpg?resize=79%2C120&ssl=1)
By Karl Ove Knausgaard
As if to make up for the digression, The Third Realm (the title also can translate as The Third Reich—very on-brand for Knausgaard) is nearly too carefully tied to The Morning Star. It options a lot of the identical characters and a number of the identical incidents; the foremost distinction is that Knausgaard is telling them largely from new factors of view. For instance: In The Morning Star, we met Arne, a good-looking however somewhat uninteresting educational who’s attempting to maintain his household collectively whereas his spouse, an artist named Tove, wrestles with delusions. The Third Realm places us as a substitute in Tove’s head, a blast furnace of artistic fury and intrusive hallucinations that compete together with her household for her consideration. “Hell isn’t the psychosis,” Tove says. “Hell is leaving the psychosis. Hell on earth is what that’s.”
After six volumes of My Battle, an uncharitable reader (like me) may need suspected Knausgaard of being a one-POV pony, however the folks in The Third Realm are as vivid and convincing as Knausgaard’s autobiographical persona. Along with Tove, we get Gaute (a schoolteacher), Kathrine (a pastor married to, and bored of, Gaute), Line (an H&M gross sales clerk), Helge (an architect), Jarle (a neurologist), Geir (a policeman and philanderer), Ramsvik (a semiconscious stroke sufferer), and Syvert (the undertaker from e-book two with the key half sister). My Battle has turn out to be Their Battle. We comply with them by way of their days, watching as they textual content, drive, make small discuss, ponder infidelity, have lunch, brush their tooth, smoke, take into consideration loss of life, drink dismaying portions of alcohol, and pull it collectively for the youngsters. The H&M employee dates a musician. The architect goes to work. The neurologist consults on a case. A few of them meet one another; a few of them don’t. All of them lookup on the star—“It was pale,” Helge thinks, “just like the solar’s ailing sister.”
Knausgaard’s writerly self-discipline is formidable. Most novelists freely pump the fuel and the brakes, zipping by way of the boring bits to get to the great ones, however his pacing is remorselessly regular, the metronome locked at 60, one second per second. He transcribes each trivial change in actual time. He doesn’t exhibit; modernists equivalent to Joyce and Woolf trafficked in mundane particulars too (“Mrs. Dalloway mentioned she would purchase the flowers herself”), however they used them as uncooked materials for wild stylistic experiments. The warmth of Knausgaard’s prose by no means exceeds room temperature. Why ought to it? The world isn’t right here to entertain you. Neither is he.
I understand how this sounds. And it’s a lot—The Third Realm, at 512 pages, is the shortest e-book within the collection. There’s positively some standard plot in there: Is Kathrine dishonest on Gaute? May Helge have saved the sufferer of that automotive crash he witnessed as a toddler? What ought to Jarle title his monograph on neuroscience (it’s not a Knausgaard novel with out an embedded monograph)? Nonetheless, I’ll personal that among the suspense for me was the meta-suspense of whether or not I’d crack beneath the pressure of paying consideration.
However Knausgaard is taking part in a subtly totally different sport right here than he was in My Battle. Blended in with the on a regular basis dross are a couple of sparkly flecks of strangeness, curious anomalies that is perhaps clues to a bigger thriller. Murders, as an example: Simply because the star seems, three members of a death-metal band have been discovered lifeless within the woods, and never simply lifeless however skinned. Additionally, unnatural herds of crabs roam the land, and a brain-dead affected person who’s about to have his organs harvested immediately revives on the working desk. If this have been a Tintin comedian, this stuff would finally lead us to a Moroccan opium-smuggling operation. In The Third Realm, they don’t—but it surely’s weirder than that. They’re not related, however they’re not not related both. As readers, we’re all conspiracy theorists, trying to find patterns, attempting to place collectively an even bigger image. However Knausgaard retains refusing to substantiate or deny the existence of any bigger thriller or which means behind the eccentricities, the end result being that you just begin hallucinating connections to fill within the gaps. Quickly you’re seeing them everywhere. Every part in The Third Realm exists in a sort of Schrödingerian superposition, clue and not-clue on the identical time.
The characters expertise their very own tales this fashion. They’re all the time wanting on the star and projecting their fervent however completely unsubstantiated theories onto it. “Individuals wished pleasure,” scoffs Jarle, who fancies himself a person of science. “They wished mysteries, they wished the unknown.” Everyone in The Third Realm is obsessive about coincidences and what they may or won’t signify. One in every of Gaute’s college students mutters in her sleep, and it feels like she’s saying the phrases heavenly star, besides that the phrases are in Hindi, a language the coed doesn’t converse. “May or not it’s coincidence?” Gaute asks himself. “It needed to be, there was no different rationalization.” Syvert, the undertaker, finds his enterprise drying up as a result of there have been no deaths for the reason that thriller star appeared. “It was coincidence, in fact. However what number of coincidences did it take for one thing to not be coincidence?” Is it noise, or sign? And if it’s sign, what’s it signaling?
The impact is exasperating however enthralling. It’s such as you’re trapped in an infinite line on the DMV, however on the identical time you’re inside a police procedural that’s in flip caught inside a horror film. All the e-book appears to flip backwards and forwards, like an optical phantasm, from literary novel to style thriller and again once more. The world is drab and pedestrian, however all the time simply behind it trembles some apocalypse or ecstatic revelation that would break by way of at any second! Or not! Both approach, you may’t cease studying. Early on within the e-book, there’s a title drop:
When [Line’s metalhead boyfriend] spoke concerning the Third Realm, it wasn’t the Nazis he was speaking about however one thing folks had believed within the Center Ages, that the First Realm was the age of God, the Second Realm the age of Christ, the Third Realm the age of the Holy Spirit.
I’m unsure precisely what he means—Line isn’t fairly certain both—but when the Holy Spirit is one thing transcendent and omnipresent but in addition diffuse and actually laborious to clarify, he is perhaps onto one thing. It’s not a lot of a spoiler to say that The Third Realm doesn’t tidy up all its tangled threads, however hope springs everlasting. Knausgaard has already printed e-book 4 in Norway, Nattskolen (“The Evening College”), with one or two extra anticipated after that.
You’ll be able to see why this type of writing could be a logical subsequent step for Knausgaard, after the strenuous naturalism of My Battle and the largely autobiographical Seasons Quartet that adopted it. He’s all the time had one thing of a mystical streak, however with out the comfort of any standard spiritual religion, so it’s no surprise that after so many pages spent wandering within the desert of the actual, he’s began seeing oases, or mirages, or probably each directly. It’s a concession, possibly, that there are realms of human expertise higher served by one thing aside from orthodox realism, and in addition by genres aside from literary fiction—thrillers, mysteries, science fiction, fantasy, horror. Knausgaard’s characters like to consider themselves as dwelling in respectable actuality, however they’re always besieged by the fantastical; it seethes on the corners of their imaginative and prescient, as insanity, dream, reminiscence, love, drunkenness, jealousy, neurological catastrophe (at the least three folks in The Third Realm have strokes), or holy ecstasy. Like plucky journalists, they believe the world of harboring some hidden which means, one thing fantastic and horrible, and so they gained’t relaxation till they discover out what it’s.
If you purchase a e-book utilizing a hyperlink on this web page, we obtain a fee. Thanks for supporting The Atlantic.